How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza

Written By Acacia Crossley


Regardless of your go-to Papa John’s Pizza pick, it is far too tempting to overload the carbs and order too much delicious pizza. Everyone knows that left-over pizza is a treat in itself, but can you still enjoy Papa John’s Pizza when it is reheated? 

To reheat Papa John’s pizza, pop it into an oven on a baking tray for around 5 to 10 minutes at 180C. You can also reheat Papa John’s pizza in the microwave or even in a skillet over a medium heat.

How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza

Papa John’s Pizza has a variety of pizzas to choose from, but they can all be reheated in similar (if not identical) ways so you can enjoy a fresh-tasting pizza the next day. Try one of these methods below for the best reheated pizza: 

How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in the Oven

Papa John’s Pizza is best reheated in an oven as with most fast-food pizzas, including Domino’s.

In fact, Papa John’s Pizza provides their own instructions on their takeaway pizza boxes which tells customers how to reheat their leftover pizza in the oven. 

Here is how best to reheat Papa John’s Pizza in your oven: 

  1. Warm The Oven 
    Set your oven to 180C and allow it to warm up for 5 minutes before you reheat your pizza. 
  2. Move To A Baking Tray 
    Take your pizza out of the takeaway box and transfer it to a baking tray. For an even reheat, space out your leftover slices if you can. 
  3. Reheat
    Place the pizza directly into your oven, preferably onto a middle wire rack, and allow the pizza to reheat for 5 minutes. 
  4. Check 
    After 5 minutes, check the middle point of your pizza. If it is piping hot, you can eat it right away. 
  5. Reheat Again 
    If your pizza is still cold after 5 minutes, reheat it for a further 5-10 minutes or until the pizza is hot to the touch. Then enjoy! 

How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in the Microwave

Usually, people avoid using their microwave to reheat pizza as the odd heat of the microwave can make the pizza dough soggy. 

However, there is a method you can use to get hot and crispy pizza in the microwave: 

  1. Prep Some Water 
    To ensure that your pizza crust gets that crispy finish, you must create some moisture in your microwave. Do this by filling a microwaveable glass or bowl with water. 
  2. Move Pizza
    Transfer your pizza from the pizza box to a microwave-safe plate small enough to fit into your microwave with space for an additional glass or bowl. 
  3. Reheat
    Place the water and the pizza into your microwave and reheat on high power for 30 seconds. 
  4. Continue To Reheat
    How long you need to reheat your pizza will vary depending on the pizza and the power of your microwave. So reheat the pizza in 30-second intervals and check that your pizza isn’t burning or drying out after every 30 seconds. 
  5. Serve! 
    When your pizza is hot to the touch, you can enjoy it right away. 

How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza on the Stove

Due to the dough thickness and shape of Papa John’s Pizza, you can use your stove to reheat any of the franchise’s pizzas. 

Better yet, when you rehydrate the dough enough, you can get that satisfyingly crispy crust back. Here is how: 

  1. Heat A Pan
    Using a sizable frying pan, put a very thin layer of oil in the bottom of the pan to prevent the pizza from sticking. Then leave the pan to warm up on medium heat. 
  2. Move The Pizza
    When the pan is hot enough, transfer your pizza directly from the pizza box to the pan. 
  3. Add Water
    The key to a crispy crust is a little bit of water. Pour just a few drops of water around the edges of your frying pan so that it reaches the sides and bottom of the pizza. 
  4. Cover
    Use a lid or plate to cover the entire top of the pizza and the pan. 
  5. Reheat
    Leave the pizza to reheat for 2-4 minutes. 
  6. Check
    Carefully lift the pizza with a spatula to check how crispy the bottom of the pizza has become. 
  7. Serve
    If the bottom of the pizza is crunchy, serve it up! If it is still a little soft, reheat for a further minute, then serve.  

How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza Successfully

It is nearly as effortless to reheat your leftover Papa John’s Pizza as it is to order it in the first place. Still, here are a few tips to ensure that you can make the most of your weekend treat: 

  • Warm To Room Temperature – You should always store leftover pizza in the fridge. When you are ready to reheat your pizza, remove it from the fridge and allow it to warm up to room temperature. This will prevent the pizza from getting too soggy when reheated. 
  • Use A Skillet – Almost everyone has a frying pan, but not everyone has a skillet. However, if you prefer to use a skillet, you will undoubtedly get that crispy pizza crust when you reheat your Papa John’s Pizza on the stove. 
  • Check The Toppings – Typically, you will know your pizza is done reheating based on the crispness of the crust. However, if you are reheating a meat pizza, you must ensure that the meat reheats until it is piping hot to kill bacteria. 

Is It Safe to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza

So long as your pizza has been stored in the fridge, you can safely reheat Papa John’s Pizza for up to 3 days after you have brought it. The biggest safety concern is mainly for meat pizzas. 

Meat can develop dangerous bacteria if not reheated thoroughly. Only reheat meat-topped Papa John’s Pizza that has been kept in the fridge for 2 days. Even then, ensure that the meat reaches a piping hot temperature before eating. 

Reheating Papa John’s FAQs

If you have more questions about reheating food from Papa John’s then these FAQs might be of use:

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Cookies?

Unfortunately, reheating Papa John’s cookies can cause them to dry out and even burn on the top. Instead, try to eat it when you receive your delivery or enjoy it cold the following day.Papa Johns Cookie

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Garlic Bread?

Yes, Papa John’s garlic bread can be reheated in a hot oven. Set the oven to around 180C, pop the garlic bread on a preheated baking tray and warm through for 10 minutes.

Leave a Comment